Social

Subscribe to Posts via Email 

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


2014 CON CALENDAR

SEPTEMBER
Wizard World, TN
Nashville, TN, Sept 26 - 28, 2014 Wizard World, Nashville, TN, Sept 26 - 28, 2014

OCTOBER
GeekGirlCon, WA
Seattle, WA, October 11-12, 2014 GeekGirlCon, Seattle, WA, October 11-12, 2014

Shop GameOnGirl
Make Custom Gifts at CafePress

Download Logo

Entries in Games (47)

Wednesday
Sep102014

Misogyny Missive: Red Dead Sexism

rdrA couple of weeks ago saw the release of Anita Sarkeesian's latest Tropes vs. Women in Video Games, which tackled the complicated issue of women serving the role as "background decoration" in modern AAA games. I haven't played the majority of the titles Anita covered in the episode, but I have played a few: Bioshock and Red Dead Redemption.

I happen to like both of these games quite a bit, but seeing the depraved acts male NPCs delivered to nondescript women hit me really, really hard. Having played through all of Bioshock and most of Red Dead Redemption, I can now see a major issue that somehow blurred by me before. And that bothers me a great deal. I'm going to focus on the latter for this piece, and may return to Bioshock later on.

In many ways, Red Dead Redemption fixed the issues I preciously held with Grand Theft Auto. The controls were better, the open world was more believable, and the protagonist was likeable. As I wandered through New Austin, I encountered situations like Anita describes in her video below:

Returning to Rockstar’s Red Dead Redemption, in most settlement areas players are treated to randomly triggered events in which female prostitutes are assaulted and murdered by johns amid a torrent of misogynistic slurs. Players are presented with the choice to either intervene and save the woman for a small cash reward or simply watch the attack play out in front of them as part of the entertainment.
CLIP: Red Dead Redemption “Help! Someone.”
“Stickin’ whore! I’m gonna cut you a new hole! You think I’m a joke? Go on then, laugh, bitch, LAUGH!”

At the time, I didn't think about the ramifications of this heinous crime; I merely acted. I saved the woman, feeling that the character John Marston would do that given how I was playing him. I tend to role play as the character when I play, trying to make decisions that fit both my ideals and the parts of the character I bond to in unison. I knew that this was a scripted event that would repeat itself, but I performed the good deed and moved on, thinking little of the overall effect this random event conveyed. But, as Anita notes:

The audience is meant to briefly gasp at these acts of brutality before their attention is directed elsewhere, towards the next event or set of enemies to be dispatched. Regardless of the player’s actions in these types of situations, the result always paints women in a regressive light, as they will end up as either “helpless damsels” or “dead victims.”

This is the kicker right here. These moments of violence against women are distractions from the main game — a minor roadblock meant to add a sense of "realism" to the world. However, women are never truly empowered in Red Dead Redemption. My experience with the game was positive when I first went through most of it (although I will admit that I didn't critically analyze these topics when I was playing it back in 2011), but I lost my save file due to an accidental save-over. I had accomplished 98% of the game by that point (including the side missions), so I just haven't had the gumption to commit to redoing all of that all over again. I put it on my Favorite list regardless, and figured I'd be game for another run sometime in the future.

Recently, before Anita's latest video, I was wondering if there was perhaps another reason I didn't feel like replaying the game. I then remembered that the women who were major players in the plot suffered terrible brutalities as well.

Bonnie MacFarlane, a quite capable woman from first impressions, is reduced to a victimized damsel to move the game's plot forward towards the end of the first third of the game. She is beaten, likely raped, and in the process of being hanged as the player works their way through the map to rescue her. Lucia Fortuna, a rebel fighting the Mexican government, is a strong-willed and significant factor in the rebellion, but is quickly tossed into the endgame of the Mexico segment of the game as a mere pawn. Wielding a knife to a gunfight, she is quickly shot down as she tries to free Abraham Reyes, leader of the uprising, leading the player towards a redemptive strike against the perpetrators for her martyrdom.

And John's wife, Abigail, is literally a damsel in distress for most of the game, serving as John's central motivation for doing all of this to the very end, where a stable life with his family is promised and then yanked away by the vindictive Edgar Ross (and the game's writers). John is gunned down by Ross' men, and Abigail is forced to watch. When Jack Marston, John's son, takes over the post-game narrative, Abigail has died from a long illness, making every single prominent woman in the game the equivalent of damaged goods...which is fitting, given how all of the women are essentially objects in the overall scheme of the game... one way or another.

So, Anita's video reminded me of all this misogyny lurking within RDR, and now makes me wonder if I really should replay it. Thus the difficulty of criticism. I liked the game, but I am repulsed by its use of women as narrative objects instead of being, you know, human beings. As Anita states in her video:

These women and their bodies are sacrificed in the name of infusing “mature themes” into gaming stories. But there is nothing mature about flippantly evoking shades of female trauma. It ends up sensationalizing an issue which is painfully familiar to a large percentage of women on this planet while also normalizing and trivializing their experiences.

It's not edgy just to throw women under the proverbial bus. It would truly be mature to not swipe from Hollywood's "adult-oriented" bag of tricks, and instead question or critique our society's standards of gender in less "shocking" ways.

I'm still trying to untangle the implications of Anita's video towards my enjoyment of video games, but I am feeling fairly confident that Red Dead Redemption, for everything it does right, made some very poor narrative decisions that will haunt my desire to ever replay it to completion again. I will still likely enjoy its excellent gameplay and exploring its open-world spin on the American West, but I will definitely not relish its disappointing, cliched portrayal of women that plagues our industry.

Wednesday
Sep032014

Some Thoughts on Super Smash Bros. and Samus Aran

I've been pondering the Smash Bros. picture of the day for August 19th...

Pic of the day. Looking at the number of days we have left for development, it would be an impossible task to create this… That's what I told my staff. But thanks to the determination of her female designer, these Zero Suit outfits got completed in time. From the ending of Metroid: Zero Mission, here's Samus in shorts!

I have a huge essay series on Samus I've wanted to write up for some time (in the meantime, Jake Shapiro does a fine job with his editorial on the matter of Samus' sexualization over at NintendoLife), but for now I'll just try to keep my thoughts on this particular image and its implications.

Super Smash Bros. Wii U and 3DS have done truly wondrous things with inclusiveness. We have female options for many new characters (the Villager, Wii Fit Trainer, Robin from Fire Emblem Awakening, and of course the Mii Fighters), and Masuhiro Sakurai has selected many newcomers that are women (Rosalina, Lucina, Patulena). Samus and Zelda have also split their alter-egos into their own characters, which adds two more women onto the roster. Truly this is one of the larger casts of playable women in a Nintendo title, and it rivals most fighting game lineups as well.

042404[1]However, we must come back to Zero Suit Samus (ZZS), the most pandering of the women appearing in this latest Smash game. Unlike Brawl, ZSS is her own character, and for people like me who like Samus in her armor  not her Zero Suit  this is a big blessing. I can fire off Zero Beams with impunity and not lose the Samus I treasure as my favorite character for the Samus I wish stopped at Metroid: Zero Mission. Ever since Zero Mission, the Zero Suit has replaced the stripteases Nintendo used to implement as a reward for speedy and/or thorough players. I didn't mind it in Zero Mission because A) I liked that stealth sequence and B) it wasn't glorified so much as a sexy alternative to armored Samus... save for a few of the endings (as seen to the left).

ssb-zero-suit-samusEver since then, however, the Zero Suit has been Nintendo's way of giving Samus an "erotic" side she never needed. Her strength and courage are demoted for attractiveness and curves. And Metroid: Other M pushed the ludicrousness of the suit to new heights with its insensible high heeled boots. For Smash, Sakurai has modified the Suit's boots to be a bit more in line with her Zero Mission look, but even these are significantly heeled and would be a burden for Samus to properly fight in, jet-equipped or not.

And then! Then we get the costume update of Fusion and Zero Mission's ending reward costumes. Now, these aren't as bad as they could be -- we do have plenty of end-game lingerie shows in the first three Metroid titles that may have been chosen instead:

nes-metroidendm2-endingbwend-sm

Thankfully, that line was not crossed. But I find most interesting in this revelation are Sakurai's comments about the alt costume. His exact words are "...but thanks to the determination of her female designer, these Zero Suit outfits got completed in time." Why include the gender of Samus' designer? Is that an attempt to stifle criticism? It's a bizarre detail that seems to be thrown in because Nintendo expected a negative reaction. If that's the case, then why include it in the first place?

In the end, Zero Suit Samus continues to be a Samus I don't care for. In the future, I will discuss these two sides of Samus in more detail. But for now, to conclude, I'm thankful ZSS is no longer tied to armored Samus in the latest Smash game, because I can now play her without any hesitations. The Varia Suit defines Samus to me — it's how I see her when I think of her, and now I can once again enjoy Smash without that image being shattered by ZSS.

Friday
Aug152014

Famicom Females: Princess Peach

peachPeach/Princess Toadstool (Super Mario Bros.)
Release Date: October 18, 1985
Developer: Nintendo
Publisher: Nintendo
Format: Cartridge
Role: NPC (Damsel)
Any Subsequent Appearances: Yes

Introduction 

Princess Toadstool, or Peach as she is known nowadays, is possibly Nintendo's most prominent female character in their line-up. She has been in the most games out of any Nintendo woman by far, and I'd have to imagine she's the one that leaps to mind for most people when they think of a female Nintendo character. In her very first appearance in the seminal Super Mario Bros., she is relegated to the very last moments of the game as the damsel in distress trapped by the villainous Koopa King Bowser.

smb-peach

Character Design and Personality

Princess Toadstool is curiously shorter than Mario in this game (that would change in the US Super Mario Bros. 2), and her sprite does not match the concept art for her at all; she has red hair, a white and red dress, and tanned skin. This color scheme is unique to this one appearance, as she adopted the pink dress and blond hair (and a fairer complexion) in Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA) and would stick with that for the rest of her appearances. Even the Japanese boxart includes her more conventional look:

smb-fami

To be honest, Pauline had more personality in terms of debuts. Peach has no animation, and after this brief message, she vanishes from view. Not the most becoming of introductions for such an iconic character, I'd say.

Impact on Narrative

Here, Peach is the definition of the “damsel in distress” trope. The point for playing the game is rescuing her. So... she is the narrative force, which is not a great motive in theory.

Positive Aspects

She has become one of Nintendo's female stalwarts. She became playable in several Mario titles (mostly in outliers like the Mario Kart series, Mario Party, and the RPGs, although Super Mario 3D World is an excellent return to her being playable in the main Mario platforming line), and was the second woman added to Super Smash Bros. (behind Metroid's Samus Aran). She has, when given the opportunity (typically in the Paper Mario series), a fairly strong-willed personality that shows that she can be quite capable despite her imprisonment. She is often featured in Super Mario merchandise, making her the most marketed woman in Nintendo's stables.

Negative Aspects 

Peach (along with Pauline and Princess Zelda) helped establish the long-running, and frankly repugnant, industry standard for women as gaming characters. Peach continues to be featured as a damsel in most of the key Mario platformers, limiting the positive agency mentioned above. Outside of the Paper Mario series, Peach is very much a stereotypical princess in the Disney mold, with a high-pitched voice and a vapid demeanor towards the action going on around her. She embodies feminine tropes (liking pink, using hearts in her attacks in certain games, utilizing her emotions to solve puzzles in Super Princess Peach, etc.).

My Reactions

Peach has never been a favorite character of mine. She's so entrenched into the damsel/princess ideal that her characterization rubs me the wrong way most of the time. Super Mario Sunshine is probably the biggest offender in marking Peach as an insipid character to me. However, I do support her Paper Mario appearances, as Intelligent Systems added some awesome depth into her personality, and gave Peach some much needed agency. On the whole, though, I'm not her biggest fan. Her flaws stick out more to me than her strengths.

Future Appearances 

Listing Peach's future appearances would be a mammoth task, so I'll touch on the three that I think made the biggest improvements to her. Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA), where Peach became playable for the first time, is #1. Her abilities were among the best in the game, particularly her floating jump, and made her a viable (and at times vital) choice for progression. The second is Super Mario RPG, which gives Peach a chance to serve as a character in Mario's three character party. She fills the role of healer, an unfortunate trope of women in RPGs, but at the very least she served a key component of many of the possible teams in the game. It gave her some characterization outside of being a damsel as well, which Intelligent Systems would expand upon in their RPGs to come. Lastly, I would argue that her addition to Super Smash Bros. Melee was her grandest hour. Being able to fight on even ground with many of Nintendo's other iconic heroes and villains was a huge increase to her agency, and she has been considered one of the better fighters in the series.

Sources  

Personal experience
Mariowiki

Wednesday
Jul022014

Misogyny Missive: Lufia II: Rise of the Sexism

Selan's artwork doesn't really portray strength, but trust me: she can bring the hammer down.As I’ve mentioned before, I have a tendency to play as female characters in video games, if the option presents itself. I’m still searching for the exact motivation for me to do so, but I think I’ve recently come to one of the reasons: it allows me a glimpse into a perspective I don’t get to see as a male. Despite being a feminist and despite my zeal for equality among the sexes and genders, I am still shackled into male conformity in society. People who don’t know my beliefs often spout some sexist or stereotypically-gendered nonsense when talking to me, and it’s frustrating beyond words. Occasionally I slip into such garbage myself; an unfortunate side effect of growing up in this misogynistic culture. I hate it, but I can’t erase who I am in the real world.

I can, however, step into a virtual space and embrace different viewpoints: those of a woman primary among them. Oftentimes, this has its own burden: sexualized costumes or bouts with what is perceived as “feminine” can wreak havoc upon my experience. One such example of the latter was in Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals for the SNES. I had been enjoying the game quite a bit, but noticed some subtle sexism underlying the narrative. Some NPC’s made some disparaging comments about some character’s physical traits, or bluntly questioned the choice of female lead Selan as the general of the Parcelyte kingdom’s military. I shrugged those off, as Selan was an awesome character in battle and more than proved herself as a valuable component of my team. I gave her all of the strength bonuses I had floating around in my inventory, and they gave her a damage boost rivaling anyone else in my party. Alongside her array of spells, Selan was a force to be reckoned with in my playthrough. Her stoic personality was all about business; she got the job done, and she did it well. She too had her own doubts about her effectiveness as a leader, but she overcame them as she defended her kingdom from harm.

Alas, this empowerment was not to last. As a crucial plot point presented itself, Maxim (the male lead) made the chauvinistic choice to send Selan and Tia – another female character – away from the party. His logic is dubious and misogynistic: they would come to harm in the fights ahead, and only the men should go on to tackle this threat. I cringed as Selan and Tia suffered this indignant command and shirked away from playable status. I lost the two most valuable members of my team, and only because the narrative felt compelled to rely on the “weak woman” trope. Selan dealt more physical damage than Maxim or Guy by this point! Both Selan and Tia had magic spells capable of damaging entire rows of monsters; their replacements did not. Maxim was feebly gifted with some magic, but he alone could not carry the party’s HP burden. And, as much of a cliché as it is, Selan and Tia could heal the entire party and they could do it well. On top of that, Guy and Dekar were packed with overwrought machismo that was a bit sickening to bear. I tried tackling the tower that followed this roster switch, but I couldn’t stomach it. The challenge was too great without Selan and Tia -- the men proved ineffective at their task. I sold the game off after this; I had no desire to play it any further.

Games allow me to witness and feel these things women feel every single day: the doubt; the anxiety; the unfairness. It’s a perspective that grants me insight and motivation to do all I can to try to alter these misconceptions about gender in games. It’s disempowering in some ways, because I’ve seen these actions inflict so many narratives and cripple too many characters over the years. The industry has dug itself into a mighty rut. However, that doesn’t mean that things will never change. What I witness is what other like-minded people witness. And more and more of those people are becoming engaged and proactive. They’re creating games, criticizing faults through writing and other forms of media, and speaking out about the injustices. I’m proud to be counted among them.

As this feature progresses, I intend to point out these issues as they lurk in certain games, all in the hopes of countering against their use in the future. I hope you will join me in the endeavor and find your own voice and reasons to fight against misogyny in video games. Feel free to share yours in the comments!

Sunday
Jun082014

Bionic Commando/Top Secret: Hitler no Fukkatsu (NES/Famicom)

Study 5 – Bionic Commando/Top Secret: Hitler no Fukkatsu (NES/Famicom, Capcom)

Capcom's early NES/Famicom output was primarily releasing straight arcade ports onto the console, often with the aid of the dubious Micronics doing the heavy lifting. After the release of Mega Man, however, Capcom began shifting more of their design teams onto the Famicom, and were more willing to tinker and reinvent their arcade ideas for the system. The greatest example of this remolding is easily 1988's Top Secret: Hitler no Fukkatsu, better known here as Bionic Commando.

Bionic Commando was one of Capcom's arcade action titles that was ultimately undercooked for its initial release. It took the protagonist of their overhead shooter Commando, Super Joe, and outfitted him with a bionic arm to swing across chasms and to grapple high platforms. Joe couldn't actually jump at all, so the arm was vital to make any progress! It's a decent game, but it didn't do a lot with its unique mechanic and premise. The levels were more about piling on the enemies and climbing up long, arduous areas than featuring much actual platforming, making it more of a standard action game without a jump button than something distinct.

When the Famicom port rolled around, Capcom decided to revisit the idea of the bionic arm, but this time reinvented the entire gameplay mechanic. In short, they made the arm a crucial aspect of the level design. A new hero, Radd Spenser, was invented to carry on the Bionic Commando mantle, and Super Joe was regulated to being a P.O.W. Capcom pioneered a new Nazi uprising for its antagonistic force, and Spenser would need to infiltrate their base, rescue Super Joe, and destroy the Albatross Project during his mission.

The word "Nazi" probably raised some eyebrows. The American Bionic Commando lacks any direct mentioning of the regime, and the only allusion made to Nazism is the surprising likeness the main villain Master-D has to Adolf Hitler. The Bionic Commando we received is different from the Japanese original, which was dubbed Top Secret: Hitler no Fukkatsu. The subtitle literally means "Resurrection of Hitler"; it's clear that from the start Capcom's original intentions was shooting down Nazis and defeating the revived Hitler. Nintendo of America's strict censorship policies barred Nazism from being carried over to the NES, and so Capcom stripped out the majority of the game's Nazi references. The Nazis were renamed the BADD's, and Hitler's name was changed to Master-D. However, despite the radical alteration to the game's plot and themes, Capcom left in some shocking moments that are breathtaking in their audacity. Before getting into that, though, let's take a look at the boxes.

Click to read more ...